Call for Proposals: Growing the Field of Chaplaincy Research in Palliative Care






 

FAQs

 

General Questions about the Initiative

What kinds of projects does HCC seek to fund?
 
How many grants will be made through this solicitation?

What won’t the initiative fund?

Do you limit the number of applications you will accept from an institution or organization?  

Does the program prefer to fund investigators in medical fields?

Do you fund qualitative research?

How can grant funds be used?


About the Application Process

Can I contact someone to discuss my proposed project and help me determine whether it is appropriate for this program?

Where can I find help identifying a board-certified chaplain to participate on my research team?

Where can I find help identifying experienced researchers who might be interested in collaborating on a project for this initiative?

Can I be serve as the chaplain on a research team if I am not board-certified?

Can I submit an application if I have an active grant from the John Templeton Foundation?


Can I include more than three lead investigators in my proposed project?

What is the page limit for the proposal narrative?

What font, font size, and margins should I use for my proposal narrative?

Can I submit a full CV instead of an NIH Biosketch?

What kinds of grant products/outcomes do you seek?


What is the maximum amount of funding that I can request?

Does that include indirect costs?  

What guidance can you provide on project length (maximum of 18 months)?

What steps can I take to develop a high-quality proposal?

Can I send a draft of my proposal to HCC for review prior to submitting it?

Can I submit more than one proposal?

Can I submit my own application and be included as a Co-Principal Investigator on another application?  

What is the application deadline and late submission policy?

How can I check the status of my application once it is submitted?

Who will review my application?

How will my application be evaluated?

When will I find out if I have been selected to receive a grant?

Can I receive feedback or reviewer comments on my application?

 

About the Grant Awards

What is the time period (start/end dates and duration) for these grants?

What is required of grantees?

 

About the Online Application System

How do I create a username and password?

Once I’ve started an application, how do I return to the application system to complete it?

How do I recover a forgotten password?


How do I save my work?

When my application is complete, how do I submit it?

How will I know if my application was submitted successfully?

 

About the Research Team

Is the research team limited to three people?

Must the experienced researchers on the team have a doctorate or are clinician investigators with research training acceptable?

Must the project director be a chaplain?

Is it assumed that the chaplain researcher is the same person as the one who is providing the care? Or can this be two or more different chaplains?

What would happen if the chaplain changed jobs before the study was completed?

Are there limitations regarding consultants – number per project, budget?

May I serve as a consultant on a project if I submit an application of my own?

Will CPE students be able to participate in the project?

 

About the Proposed Research Projects

Will selection preference be given for qualitative or quantitative methods?

What do you mean by innovation?

Can you give examples of mixed methods?

Should the subjects of the study be diverse?

Are studies related to religion-specific populations acceptable?

Are you open to topics that are central to spiritual care provision but not exclusive to the profession of chaplaincy?

Does your definition of palliative care include hospice care?

Will studies that address issues with underserved or disadvantaged populations be given added consideration?

Will studies that focus on children and adolescents be considered?

Will studies that focus on veterans with traumatic brain injury or PTSD be considered?

How about perinatal palliative care, where the patient is the family?

Can we contact HCC for feedback on potential research design?

What is the expected final product? Can work on publications continue after the project ends?

 

Other

What do you mean by a diverse applicant pool?

What kinds of support will HCC provide for the research team?

One of the stated goals of the project is to create a cadre of chaplain researchers. However, it is not clear how chaplains are going to gain enough training over the course of this grant to become independent researchers.

Does the project have to start on July 1, 2012? We need time to hire an extra chaplain.

Should the budget be done in a specific format?

Are appendices to the proposal permitted?

What kinds of evidence of institutional support are you looking for?

What is the schedule for the colloquia and where will they be held?

Can grant funds be used to support dissertation research? Other educational expenses?

 

General Questions about the Initiative

Q:  What kinds of projects does HCC seek to fund?
A:   Because of the state of the field of chaplaincy research, we are looking for research teams who will propose field-advancing projects that will identify and explore hypotheses about chaplains’ contributions to palliative care using qualitative, quantitative or mixed methods.  Studies to identify suitable measures for future hypothesis testing research will also be welcome.  See the section on Proposal Development in the CFP for examples of areas of inquiry.  Proposals can also be based on investigator-initiated ideas consistent with this initiative’s objective.    

Q:  How many grants will be made through this solicitation?
A:  We expect to make approximately 6-10 awards for this solicitation.

Q:  What won’t the initiative fund?
A:   We will not fund projects by institutions located outside the United States or Canada.  We will not fund projects that are not related to palliative care.  We will not fund a project to be carried out by one investigator – we seek to fund research by teams.  

Q: Do you limit the number of applications you will accept from an institution or organization?  
A:  No, we do not impose a limit on applications per institution/organization.  We seek strong applications and aim to select a diverse group of investigators and board-certified chaplains from a range of institutions/organizations.

Q:  Does the program prefer to fund investigators in medical fields?
A:  We seek investigators from diverse fields and disciplines and do not have quotas or restrictions, with one exception.  Each project must include one or more board-certified chaplains interested and involved in palliative care, and committed to developing their research skills, and to conducting research as a significant focus of their work.

Q:  Do you fund qualitative research?
A:  We do not restrict or prefer particular research methods or types of data.  The reviewers consider whether the methods and data proposed can answer the research questions posed.

Q:  How can grant funds be used?
A:  Grant funds may be used for project staff salary, consulting expertise, data collection and analysis, other reasonable research and training expenses, supplies, project-related travel (however the colloquia travel will be paid for directly by HCC), and a limited amount of equipment deemed essential to the project.


About the Application Process
Q:  Can I contact someone to discuss my proposed project and help me determine whether it is appropriate for this program?
A:  While we cannot definitively encourage or reject a project idea by phone or email, HCC encourages applicants to contact us to discuss their research teams and proposed projects.  Please direct inquiries to Robert Wolf, Senior Vice President of Innovation and Development at jtf-applicant@healthcarechaplaincy.org.

Q:  Where can I find help identifying a board-certified chaplain to participate on my research team?
A:  Start with your own institution, tap your personal networks, or visit these web sites for more information:
Association of Professional Chaplains: www.professionalchaplains.org
National Association of Catholic Chaplains: www.nacc.org
Association for Clinical Pastoral Education: www.acpe.edu (see listing of ACPE centers under Directories tab)
National Association of Jewish Chaplains: www.najc.org
Canadian Association for Spiritual Care: www.cape.org

Q:  What font, font size, and margins should I use for my proposal narrative?

A:  You will need to use our proposal narrative form to prepare and submit your proposal narrative. The required font for your narrative is Arial size 11, with one inch margins. To access the form, please log in to the online applicant system and download the proposal narrative form. Your narrative can be developed in Word and pasted into the form.

Q:  Can I submit a full CV instead of an NIH Biosketch?
A:  No, our reviewers prefer an NIH Biosketch.

Q:  What kinds of grant products/outcomes do you seek?
A:  Several types of products may be appropriate – journal articles, presentations at professional meetings, articles for broader audiences, opinion pieces, and web sites, for example.  

Q:  What is the maximum amount of funding that I can request?
A:  $250,000.  

Q:  Does that include indirect costs?  
A:  Yes.  Indirect costs must be calculated at a rate not to exceed 15% - lower percentages are welcome.  If your budget includes a contract, please contact HCC to discuss the indirect cost calculation.  HCC reserves the right to negotiate indirect costs on all grant awards in accordance with the policies of the John Templeton Foundation.

Q:  What guidance can you provide on project length (maximum of 18 months)?
A:  Projects must be completed in 18 months or less.  Be realistic about how long your project will actually take.  Project directors will also be expected to meet all IRB requirements within their host institutions no later than September 30, 2012 and communicate IRB approval to HCC.   

Q:  What steps can I take to develop a high-quality proposal?
A:  Present your project in a way that is likely to capture the reviewers’ attention and interest.  Each reviewer reads many applications – try to make clear up front why your project is “special.”  Keep in mind that the reviewers represent a range of disciplines and points of view, and write in a way that can communicate across fields.  Be sure to read the CFP carefully, follow all instructions, and respond to all of the questions listed under the evaluation criteria.  It’s a good idea to ask a colleague to review your proposal prior to submission.

Q:  Can I send a draft of my proposal to HCC for review prior to submitting it?
A:  No.  We cannot review draft applications due to our commitment to a fair review process.

Q:  Can I submit more than one proposal?
A:  No.  

Q:  Can I submit my own application and be included as a Co-Principal Investigator on another application?  
A:  No.

Q:  What is the application deadline and late submission policy?
A:  The deadline for submitting your application online is March 15, 2012 at 3 p.m. Eastern Time.  The Applicant Project Director is responsible for ensuring that the submitted application is complete.  To be accepted for review, your application must be complete and submitted by the deadline.
To be fair to all applicants, late applications will not be accepted.  We will not accept paper applications or applications sent by email or fax.

Q:  How can I check the status of my application once it is submitted?
A:  You will be notified that your application has been received.  We will notify you again by May 31, 2012 to let you know whether you have been selected to receive a grant or to stay related to the community during the grant period.
    
Q:  Who will review my application?
A:  Your application will be reviewed by a project Advisory Committee of experts from a range of fields.  For information about our initiative’s Advisory Committee, visit http://www.healthcarechaplaincy.org/Templeton-Research-Project/Advisory-list.html
 
Q:  How will my application be evaluated?
A:  Your application will be evaluated based upon the criteria outlined in the CFP for aims, significance and innovation; investigator and research team qualifications; commitment to growing the field of chaplaincy research in palliative care; institutional and collateral support; approach and methods; feasibility and financial responsibility; and potential scholarly and public influence.

Q:  When will I find out if I have been selected to receive a grant?
A:  We will send you an email by May 31, 2012 to let you know whether or not you have been selected to receive a grant or to stay related to the community during the grant period.

Q:  Can I receive feedback or reviewer comments on my application?
A:  Due to the volume of applications, we cannot provide specific comments on individual applications.  Instead, after the grantees are announced, we will post general comments from our Advisory Committee about proposal quality at http://www.healthcarechaplaincy.org/Templeton-Research-Project.


About the Grant Awards
Q:  What is the time period (start/end dates and duration) for these grants?
A:  Grants must start on July 1, 2012 and end no later than December 31, 2013.  The awards can last up to 18 months.  Project extensions, also referred to as no-cost extensions, will not be possible.

Q:  What is required of grantees?
A:  Project directors are required to submit periodic progress and financial reports and final narrative and financial reports.  They will also be expected to meet all IRB requirements of their institutions by September 30, 2012.  The lead investigators and board-certified chaplains (not to exceed a total of 3 persons per research team) are expected to attend, at HCC’s expense (therefore this is not an expense that should be in your project budget), four to five national colloquia over the course of the initiative to network with and share their research and findings with others.  Acceptance of project funding commits grantees to participate in these colloquia, which will afford opportunities for networking, career development, and collaborations aimed at continuing to grow the emerging discipline of chaplaincy research.

 

About the Online Application System

Q:  How do I create a username and password?
A:  The first time you visit the application Login screen, you’ll need to create a username and password. You can do that by entering them on the right side of the signup box, as shown below:

Make sure you use a real email address that you can easily access. The login form is case sensitive – if you initially sign up as Test@Example.com, you wouldn’t be able to login as test@example.com.

Once you’ve done this, click Signup, and you’ll be taken to the application form. Most people won’t have all the information necessary to complete the application on the first visit. To save an application as a draft so that you may return to it later, scroll to the bottom and click the Save Draft option.

If you ever access the application from a shared computer, you might find that someone else was on the site before you. If you load the application form and don’t see the Login/Signup box displayed above, immediately scroll down, click Return to Menu, and then click Logout. After that, you can log in with your own credentials.

Q:  Once I’ve started an application, how do I return to the application system to complete it?
A:  Most people will need to come back to the application at some point. If you have started an application and saved it as a draft, it’s now associated with the email address and password you entered the very first time.

Enter your email address and password in the left hand side of the gray box and click the Login option. This will take you right back to the application you had saved as a draft.

Q:  How do I recover a forgotten password?
A:  If you’ve forgotten your password, you’ll need to click the ‘Forgot Password’ link to recover it. That will take you to a screen where we’ll ask you for the email address you used when you first created an account. Enter that as shown below and click Reset Password:

The system will send you an email which has a new, temporary password.

Back on the Wizehive window, click the “Back to Login” link, shown below:

This will return you to the main login screen. At this screen, type in your email address and the temporary password from your email:

On your screen, the password will only show up as black dots. We’re showing it here just so it’s clear that you should use the one from the email you received.

This will take you to a screen where you’ll be asked to supply a new, personalized password to replace the temporary one. Enter a password that you can easily remember in the boxes shown below, then click “Change Password and Login”

This will take you right back to the application you had in progress. The next time you return to the login screen, you’ll use your email address and the password that you typed into the boxes shown right above.

Q:  How do I save my work?
A:  Scroll down to the bottom of the application form and click the Save Draft Button.

Q:  When my application is complete, how do I submit it?
A:  Scroll down to the bottom of the application form and click Submit.

Q:  How will I know if my application was submitted successfully?
A:  You will receive an email from the system indicating that we have received your application.

 

About the Research Team

Q: Is the research team limited to three people?
A: No – there are no limits to the number of people on a team and that should depend on what’s appropriate for conducting the project. However, we intend to invite a maximum of three people per team to the colloquia, including the project director and chaplain.

Q: Must the experienced researchers on the team have a doctorate or are clinician investigators with research training acceptable?
A: The team must possess the appropriate expertise needed to carry out the project. We do not require Ph.D.’s.

Q: Must the project director be a chaplain?
A: The chaplain does not need to be a project director or co-PI. As long as a chaplain is on the research team, any arrangement is acceptable.

Q: Is it assumed that the chaplain researcher is the same person as the one who is providing the care? Or can this be two or more different chaplains?
A: You must have a board-certified chaplain on your team or a chaplain who is eligible according to common standards. How you propose to carry out the study is up to you.

Q: What would happen if the chaplain changed jobs before the study was completed?
A: We will work with teams where unavoidable personnel changes occur. However, we are interested in the commitment of the team and the individuals to this line of research and will be paying close attention to that in our review.

Q: Are there limitations regarding consultants – number per project, budget?
A: We have no limitations on consultants.

Q: May I serve as a consultant on a project if I submit an application of my own?
A: Yes.

Q: Will CPE students be able to participate in the project?
A: That is for the team to decide. If their participation is appropriate and will contribute to the project’s aims, then yes.

 

About the Proposed Research Projects

Q: Will selection preference be given for qualitative or quantitative methods?
A: We do not restrict or prefer particular research methods or types of data. The reviewers consider whether the methods and data you propose can answer the questions you seek to understand.

Q: What do you mean by innovation?
A: We are looking to support research that can advance the field. Anything already known in the literature will be of less interest to us than something that can contribute in new ways to the field of chaplaincy in palliative care.

Q: Can you give examples of mixed methods?
A: There are many examples of mixed methods studies in the literature. For example, a study might use open-ended interviews and subject them to content analysis, then analyze administrative or epidemiological data on use of chaplain services.

Q: Should the subjects of the study be diverse?
A: We’re interested in generalizability and also seek to be inclusive – diversity is viewed very positively. The reviewers will consider this in conjunction with scientific merit.

Q: Are studies related to religion-specific populations acceptable?
A: They could be. We are looking for field-advancing studies. The reviewers will consider generalizability. The study would have to generate a hypothesis that could move the field forward. We also recognize that a great deal of chaplaincy is conducted from within faith traditions including atheism and other non-traditional religions. You would need to provide scientific justification for selecting one faith tradition,

Q: Are you open to topics that are central to spiritual care provision but not exclusive to the profession of chaplaincy?
A: Yes.

Q: Does your definition of palliative care include hospice care?
A: Yes.

Q: Will studies that address issues with underserved or disadvantaged populations be given added consideration?
A: We are interested in studies that explore how chaplaincy services might be better accessed or used by disadvantaged populations.

Q: Will studies that focus on children and adolescents be considered?
A: Yes.

Q: Will studies that focus on veterans with traumatic brain injury or PTSD be considered?
A: Yes.

Q: How about perinatal palliative care, where the patient is the family?
A: Yes. We intend to be inclusive and are looking for projects that target a range of patients and settings through which palliative care is delivered.

Q: Can we contact HCC for feedback on potential research design?
A: We will avoid giving any scientific guidance as a matter of fairness. We are willing to discuss the suitability of projects for this initiative.

Q: What is the expected final product? Can work on publications continue after the project ends?
A: Depending on the project, papers, journal articles, presentations at professional meetings, opinion pieces, etc. Yes, work on publications can continue after December 31, 2013.

 

Other

Q: What do you mean by a diverse applicant pool?
A: We seek wide-ranging diversity among applicants including, but not limited to gender, ethnicity, religious denomination or spiritual tradition, under-represented groups, career stage, discipline/field, and institutional affiliation.

Q: What kinds of support will HCC provide for the research team?
A: Mentoring by our project faculty, networking opportunities, and convening through several colloquia.

Q: One of the stated goals of the project is to create a cadre of chaplain researchers. However, it is not clear how chaplains are going to gain enough training over the course of this grant to become independent researchers.
A: It is important to note that we are not necessarily looking to create "independent" chaplain researchers that will be able to run their own projects, although some may get there over time. We will consider it a large step forward if we create a cadre of chaplains who have enough research interest and sophistication to be subject matter experts in chaplaincy and spiritual care as members of research teams and can read and evaluate the literature that informs their own practice.

Q: Does the project have to start on July 1, 2012? We need time to hire an extra chaplain.
A: The grant must start on July 1, 2012 and end no later than December 31, 2012. No extensions of any kind will be possible. The team can choose how to ramp up and get started but the reviewers will be evaluating the capacity of the team and how they plan to work together to achieve the project aims.

Q: Should the budget be done in a specific format?
A: Yes. You can access sample templates and detailed application instructions through our online application system – you must register and log in to access this information.

Q: Are appendices to the proposal permitted?
A: We discourage the inclusion of appendices. Please contact us to discuss their relevance.

Q: What kinds of evidence of institutional support are you looking for?
A: We are looking for a letter from an institutional executive with the authority to ensure that proposed project staff will be given the time and resources needed to carry out the research and participate in the colloquia.

Q: What is the schedule for the colloquia and where will they be held?
A: The first colloquium will be held in New York on Sept. 13-14, 2012. Others will be announced at a later date.

Q: Can grant funds be used to support dissertation research? Other educational expenses?
A: Grant funds are to be used to support the conduct of research studies – this is not a career development initiative. Funds cannot be used to support dissertation research or tuition for full-time coursework. However, small amounts of funds may be used to support registration in professional conferences or short-term education programs, trainings, seminars, etc. If you have a question about proposed education expenses, please contact us.

 


Q: Where can I find help identifying experienced researchers who might be interested in collaborating on a project for this initiative?
A: Start with your own institution, tap your personal networks, inquire at universities with research institutes or centers in your region, contact professional organizations, or visit these web sites for more information:
AcademyHealth:
http://www.academyhealth.org/
NIH Research Portfolio Online Reporting Tools: http://report.nih.gov/
National Palliative Care Research Center: http://www.npcrc.org/
American Sociological Association: http://asanet.org/sections/religion.cfm

Q: Can I be serve as the chaplain on a research team if I am not board-certified?
A: Anyone who is either board-certified or eligible according to Common Standards may apply or serve as the chaplain on a research team.

Q:  Can I submit an application if I have an active grant from the John Templeton Foundation?
A:  Yes.

Q:  Can I include more than three lead investigators in my proposed project?
A:  Projects may have up to three leaders.  If small amounts of additional expertise are needed for the project, it is possible to use a consultant.  Given HCC’s intent to develop sustainable, collaborative research networks focused on chaplaincy care, teams must include, in a participatory and engaged role, one or more board-certified chaplains.

Q:  What is the page limit for the proposal narrative?
A:  Twelve single-spaced pages, excluding references.